Meaning
Treaty provision designed to prevent residents of third countries from obtaining the tax benefits of a bilateral agreement through the use of shell companies. A limitation on benefits clause establishes strict eligibility criteria, such as ownership requirements or active trade tests, to ensure the entity has a real connection to the treaty country. It stops treaty shopping, where a firm sets up a nominal office in a specific nation just to access its favorable tax network.
Eligibility Standard
Entities must typically satisfy one of several objective tests, such as being a publicly traded company or having at least half of their shares held by local residents. The limitation on benefits rules also include a base erosion test, which looks at whether the company uses its income to make deductible payments to non residents. This prevents the siphoning of profits out of the treaty country through interest or royalty payments to a low tax jurisdiction.
A derivative benefits test might also apply if the owners are residents of countries with similar treaty protections.
Administrative Burden
Companies must provide extensive documentation and residency certificates to prove they meet these rigorous standards before any withholding tax relief is granted. If the limitation on benefits requirements are not met, the higher statutory tax rates of the source country apply.
Discretionary Relief
Competent authorities may grant benefits if a company can prove that its establishment was not for treaty-cheating purposes.